My Journey

I have made all the calculations; fate will do the rest -(Napoleon)

Friday, December 14, 2007

Democracy - the Indian way !


I don’t often mention Indian politics on my blog. Not that I am not political, on the contrary, I am strongly political in my views. But when it comes to India, there are so many things to develop upon than politics, that too at the state level.

Much has been said about Indian democracy, said to be one of the world’s biggest and vibrant one. In India, democracy might be what it is defined in dictionaries, but not what it is envisaged as. Some time ago, when Economist termed Indian democracy as patchy, many people didn’t agree. I can’t see why, and the present case in point, one of the Western states of India- Gujarat. It is ruled by the worst person living - leader of the state BJP (a Hindu rightwing party).

Those who don’t know about Narendra Modi or his party BJP would not be able to understand my hatred for him. But he and his party were ruling Gujarat in 2002 - when about 2000 people were massacred.

The immediate reason for writing about him is this excellent article, carried again in Economist. I would just quote the lines from that article

AS A cheerleader for the emerging India, a giant democracy with—at last—an economy to match, Narendra Modi is a disgrace.”

With the ongoing elections in Gujarat, Modi is again trying to keep his job. I have had only few Gujarati friends, so I don’t exactly understand the Gujarati mindset that elected him with absolute majority in 2002. The Economist article further mentions,

Its last election, later in 2002, gave Mr Modi a thumping majority, biggest in those districts where the bloodshed was worst.

The line above totally describes the voting pattern in 2002 elections of Gujarat and the following gives some hint about the average person who casts his/her vote in Gujarat.

Meanwhile, few commentators have dwelt on the poll's most depressing aspect: Congress's own careful reluctance to mention the 2002 massacre—let alone Mr Modi's alleged part in it. This makes electoral sense. Attacking Mr Modi for failing to protect Muslims might remind Gujaratis why they used to like him so much.

I don’t trust much the election predictions, not even those made by psephologist. If Narendra Modi gets to keep his job then I guess average voter of Gujarat will have lot of explaining to do.

Few even go so far to suggest that one day this hated person will become the Prime Minister of India. If this happens then the only thing I could do is to give away my Indian citizenship. It would be better than hanging my head in shame for the democracy, which would be India.

Labels:

5 Comments:

  • At 4:52 PM, Blogger XVSA013 said…

    he will die a miserable death ...

     
  • At 4:15 AM, Blogger Abhinav said…

    Whoa!! Strong words .. i agree with ya but not in totality.

    Whatever happened in 2002 was a shame however who are to blame for his win in the past or may be this time. As i have mentioned in my blog so many times it is us WE THE PEOPLE.

    Why do we fall in their (politicos) trap year on year every election? If people understand this such personalities across political spectrum will not reach the top.

    a Hindu rightwing party Man atleast dont do the western talk here, we all know who is what in India, we dont use such terms, let it for the likes of CNN et al.

    If this happens then the only thing I could do is to give away my Indian citizenship what wud u say abt ppl not born in India becoming PM, that wud be a far more disgrace than Modi being PM. You have got 2 reasons to let go ut Indian citizenship :P

     
  • At 7:20 PM, Blogger educatedunemployed said…

    If this happens then the only thing I could do is to give away my Indian citizenship And then?

    I might not be the person to comment over this post as I don't have an opinion over this subject matter. How ever you do know that I have been very interested in politics in the past.

    So interesting point of view. How ever I find a sense of escapism in your tone. Which might be the best thing to do in circumstances we have little control over.

    How ever passing judgements over a religiously biased community and illiterate at that is really pointless don't you think? what has the educated, elitist, or capable mind set in India done or thought about it. And by that I mean people like you and me.

     
  • At 6:19 AM, Blogger Expression ! said…

    I stopped following Indian politics anymore ,it is disappointing me a lot.This weeks economist has an article about Indian politics that BJP is going to pick his "octogenarian" leader Advani.
    I am totally against that.

     
  • At 4:00 PM, Blogger greensatya said…

    Mowgli - That I am sure of! no one with blood of so many people on his hand would be spared ! Karma is there.


    Abhinav - Whether we borrow it from CNN or try to escape the reality by not mentioning it, the truth will remain. BJP is a Hindu right wing party.

    In democrarcy, the rule of crowd works. So what can a single person do if the average population of a state is communal.

    I don't mind someone from foreign origin becoming India's PM. Birth is not a criteria, otherwise you people would not object Musharraf becoming India's president.

    EU - You must be knowing that Democracy works in a strange manner. Right or wrong does not work, what works is majority opinion be it right or wrong. It depends on the majority of the stakeholder to present right perso and others to elect right person. A mature democratic system will have inherent checks and balances to ensure this. That's why I said, India is not a matured democracy.

    The other takeaway from the above paragraph is that in democracy, single person can't do enough and if you take the hypothetical situation of brining change, it would take centuries. So yeah, there is sense of escapism and now helplessness.

    Expression - Yeah I agree ! What I don't understand is an average Gujarati electorate, how can they be so communal ?

     

Post a Comment

<< Home