My Journey

I have made all the calculations; fate will do the rest -(Napoleon)

Monday, September 18, 2006

Sweden's election result - chink in the Scandinavian model ?


The results of Sweden's general election, though revolutionary wasn't much of surprise. In the days leading to election, it was increasingly getting clear that incumbent Social Democrats party will be ousted from government. The party, led by Prime Minister Goran Persson has been in power continuously for past 12 years. It was overthrown yesterday, by the centre-right alliance under the leadership of Fredrik Reinfeldt, who is set to become the new prime minister.

On paper, it is difficult to find out why the government of Prime Minister Goran Persson failed to win? The GDP growth of Sweden is around 5.6%, the highest in Europe, and Sweden is the shining jewel of the Scandinavian model. This Scandinavian model, which is the best example of a welfare state was under attack(milder than 2002) by the opposition party. So are we going to see the collapse of Scandinavian model ?

For the last few years, mainland Europe has always been looking at their northern counterparts with admiration for their high fuelled economy, alongside the best social security that any country could offer. Infact last year, when there was spat between England and France, over the Anglo-Saxon and Franco-German model, this North European model or Scandinavian model, was touted to be the best model to follow. This amount of extensive social security comes at a price; people in this region pay the highest amount of tax. Also the government holds the monopoly in few sectors, making it possible for them to generate revenue to meet the cost of social benefits. Other countries of Europe, like France and Germany, they also have fair amount of social security benefits for its citizens, but they are now getting over burdened with it. The industries in these countries are threatened by those from free market economies of the global world. Among all this, the Scandinavian model was the one every one looked upon for social security as well as prosperity. In fact in Sweden, it was encouraging enough for people to even remain unemployed and get benefits than to be in a regular job.

So the election result of Sweden, which brought to power a party which never approved the high social security coverage, may reduce the charm of Scandinavian model. The PM to be, Mr Fredrik Reinfeldt has announced reduction in social security benefits, lower tax rates and also to end government control of economy in certain ways. Though Mr Reinfeldt is not expected to take any drastic and dramatic change in the model, the trend he starts will be of interest to many other countries. May be, he has just exposed the chink in the Scandinavian model.

9 Comments:

  • At 6:11 PM, Blogger XVSA013 said…

    i dont know anything abt Scandinavia ... but good intro ... thanks.

     
  • At 7:08 PM, Blogger Y said…

    If we look at the progress of institutions - econimic and political- across the world, over the last century, we will see that the central pattern is that all institutions have morphed in response to the human search for freedom.

    So thats how I look at these events.

     
  • At 9:29 PM, Blogger Koi Pahailee said…

    Very Interesting.
    can u tell what is the tax rate in Sweden?

     
  • At 9:35 AM, Blogger P said…

    Don't know anything about the topic in question but you've gotten me sufficiently interested!

     
  • At 11:04 AM, Blogger greensatya said…

    Appu - India is uniquely placed in the whole debate. But first a bit of clarification. It might have sounded by my post, but there is no big brotherly government here. It is just with regards to high level of social security that government provides.

    Coming to India, our constitution defines India as a welfare state. We pay taxes for it (which is not less compared to Scandinavian countries) and we don't get any social security !! So I said unique case.
    I am travelling very soon, will be in India in the first days of October.

    Mowgli - Welcome :)

    Sher - Wow, that went straight above my head !!

    Koi - I am not sure about tax rate in Sweden, but here in Finland, I pay personal income tax of 39.4%. Sweden's tax rate would be close by.

    Perspective - So the post was worth it :)

     
  • At 4:53 PM, Blogger Unknown said…

    *nods and smiles*
    yeah..exactly. what i said..really..hmmm..i knowwww!!

    :-) will read later. thanks for the attempt at educating me.

     
  • At 10:01 AM, Blogger greensatya said…

    Ipanema Girl - You are too modest :) and that's cool !

     
  • At 4:59 PM, Blogger Koi Pahailee said…

    Then I guess the complain of UK citizens about paying the highest tax and not getting good service from Government is valid after all.
    wat do u say

     
  • At 10:26 PM, Blogger greensatya said…

    Koi - Yeah, I guess their complain is justified. I never knew that UK is also lax in its macromanagement of Economy.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home